Gov. Mike Braun announced today that “affordability” will be the watchword of his campaign for reelection. That is disappointing. Why? Because coming from an official it is assumed that “affordability” will attempt to be achieved through some sort of disjointed, ineffectual government action.
And it can be assumed that anything constructive coming out of our Statehouse, Democrat or Republican, will be far short of what is happening in Ron Desantis’s booming Florida or — if we are shooting for the moon — Javier Milei’s Argentina.
So we ask the three questions we always ask of political posture: “According to whom?” “At what cost?” and “Compared with what?”
The first has already been answered, that is, politicians are the ones telling us that affordability is a realistic statist goal, that officialdom can make things cheaper. That of course is what those seeking office have always told us. It can be discounted out of hand.
The next, “At what cost?,” takes more thought. Price controls, rent freezes, expanded subsidies and rules against price-gouging produce shortages, reduce quality or raise costs elsewhere. Indeed, the price paid for anything the governor might subsidize or regulate falls only because someone else pays the difference.
Finally, “Compared with what?” is an accountant’s nightmare. Are we comparing current incomes, 2019 prices, median wages or some idealized standard of living? If a household’s real purchasing power has risen, for example, but its housing costs have risen faster because of local supply constraints, is the problem affordability or a mismatch between demand and supply?
In sum, the slogan seems another way of promising something whose failure can later be sloughed off on someone else. We hope we are wrong; we hope Braun plans to shut down a department or two, reduce taxes to 1912 levels and cut the higher-education budget in half. If not, the real watchword is “unaccountability.”
There is a way, however, the governor could make life more affordable for Hoosiers. He could announce that heretofore the Indiana citizenry, as far as is humanely possible, will be expected to be self-reliant (especially its able-bodied men regardless of race or national origin) and that Indiana businesses will be expected to be competitive and productive independent of government aid or favor.
For it is by making yourself more useful, by finding a better job and by keeping more of a paycheck that life becomes more “affordable.” It has little to do with the governor’s office. Yes, it would help if Washington would quit printing money to pay for unconstrained and corrosive spending, but that is another essay. — tcl
