by Richard McGowan, Ph.D.
I have been down this road before, hence, it pains me to write another account of how unwarranted it is that people persist in saying “women are understudied.”
The special issue on medical care and hospitals, published annually by the U.S. News and World Report, had an article that stated “Women’s Health is Chronically Under Studied and Underfunded. It’s Time for a Change.”
It is unwarranted to assert that women are understudied compared with men.
Nonetheless, the idea of women being understudied was in President Trump’s mind on Oct. 19 when he delivered Executive Order 14437, “Advancing Women’s Health to Improve Outcomes in All Phases of Life.”
President Trump stated that “many diseases and conditions that disproportionately or uniquely affect women have not received the level of research, clinical attention, and treatment that other diseases and conditions have received.” The order also provided for the establishment of a “Women’s Health Division within the National Institutes of Health (NIH) alongside a White House Women’s Health Task Force.” The NIH has no corresponding “Men’s Health Division.”
Among the identified “diseases and conditions that disproportionately or uniquely affect women” is aging.
Aging is not unique to women. Does aging disproportionately affect women?
Data from the Center for Disease Control (CDC) show that a man’s lifespan is 4.9 fewer years than a woman’s lifespan. The NIH’s database, PubMed, the compendium of research and investigation, lists 43,253 items under “aging and men” to 71,648 under “aging and women.” I suppose the larger number of articles listed for ‘aging and women’ occur in the last 5 or so years of their life, when men are no longer aging.
What other diseases or conditions allegedly affect women “disproportionately or uniquely?” The executive order named several medical problems “critical” to women’s health, “including cardiovascular and heart disease, cancer, stroke, Alzheimer’s Disease, autoimmune and inflammatory conditions, osteoporosis, mental health, chronic pain, endometriosis, fibroids, polyendocrine metabolic ovary syndrome, infertility, maternal health, menopause, neurological disorders, aging, and more.” Are men afflicted by cancer and cardiovascular disease? How about stroke and mental health? Regarding mental health, data show that men, in all age cohorts, commit suicide about four times more than women.
As for cancer, CDC data show that men are 1.4 times more likely to die from cancer compared to women. The 2020 CDC data show that 170 men per 100,000 males died from cancer while 124 women per 100,000 died from cancer. Or, men are disproportionately impacted by cancer.
For the years 2009-2019, the CDC observed that “Over the past decade, males were nearly twice as likely as females to die of heart disease.” That men suffer more death from heart disease has not changed since 2019. KFF, which describes itself as “the leading health policy organization,” states that in 2024, 376,875 men died from heart disease to 300,616 women. Men are disproportionately impacted by heart disease. Given the data, a Men’s Health Division ought to be instituted since men are disproportionately impacted by cancer and heart disease, the leading causes of death for both men and women.
And despite the data on morbidity, PubMed lists 130,980 items under “heart disease and women” and 71,408 items under “heart disease and men.” Under “cancer and women,” PubMed lists 443,110 items but a relatively paltry 131,980 under “cancer and men.” More research and investigation focuses on women than on the disproportionately affected men.
In fact, every medical issue listed in Executive Order 1477 has more entries in PubMed under the disease and women compared to entries under the same disease and men.
PubMed lists 45,040 items under “stroke and women” and 26,082 items under “stroke and men.” In several instances, like the disparity in cancer articles, PubMed lists more than twice the number of articles focusing on women compared to articles focusing on men. Alzheimer’s disease, autoimmune and inflammatory conditions, mental health, chronic pain, osteoporosis — all of which impact men and women — have more than twice the entries under women in PubMed compared to entries under men.
Perhaps Order 14437 simply followed the 1993 NIH Revitalization Act requiring research to be more inclusive by sex. The legislation made little sense then, too. Under “women and research from 1980 to 1992,” PubMed lists 46,013 items; in those same years for “men and research,” it lists 22,821. Further, in those same years, clinical research, the ‘gold standard’ of research, saw PubMed list 7,095 items under “women and clinical research” to 3,954 items under “men and clinical research.” A broader PubMed search, one without time limits, shows 355,744 entries under “clinical research and women” and 130,154 entries for “clinical research and men.”
Given the data, the 1993 legislation was unwarranted, the recent article in the US News and World Report was unwarranted, and so was Executive Order 14437. The article in the US News and World Report referred to musculoskeletal health, osteoarthritis, and endometriosis. PubMed lists more entries under each disease, clinical research and women than the disease, clinical research, and men. Why does the idea that women are under studied persist?
A short answer to that question involves human nature and “identity.” It is in a person’s nature to have strongly held views of the world, views that constitute an individual’s identity. Challenges to a world view, even data-driven challenges, are a threat to a person’s identity. And as Plato observed, changing an identity is risky business. In every dialogue, the life of Socrates is threatened. Institutions can feel threatened, too. The medieval Church understood perfectly well what a threat it would be for people to think the sun was the center of the universe — and a threat to the Church, too. Are scientists threatened by the data from PubMed? Are politicians? Are journalists?
Threats notwithstanding, the sun is indeed the center of the universe.
Richard McGowan, Ph.D., an adjunct scholar of the Indiana Policy Review Foundation, has taught philosophy and ethics cores for more than 40 years, most recently at Butler University. Sources for this article can be accessed at www.inpolicy.org.
Sources
PubMed
https://www.usnews.com/opinion/articles/2025-12-04/women-health-tiktok-research-opinion
