Individual Responsibility: A Revival

My city’s Urban League this week released its “State of the City,” much lauded by the local media, and, mercifully, the only one in a decade. There is the usual listing of black-white disparities and the continued concern that the white community is not doing enough to help. But there is something new, a hint that blacks are claiming responsibility for their individual situations, good or bad.

In all, especially considering the diatribes and guilt trips that predominate in the field of community research, the report was impressively well done. Prepared by Rachel Blakeman of Purdue University, it is a valuable research tool for political and governmental projects. Its action steps, although weighted toward statist remedies, are generally thoughtful and based. Particularly commendable is the advice that blacks focus individually on education as a job-getter and on home ownership as a financial strategy — an improvement over four decades of pushing education as status and welfare as income.

Still, we need a reminder of what is always missing in such reports, e.g., that disparity is not necessarily discrimination. The Urban League starts off well enough in that regard, with its president asserting, “We cannot change what we do not measure; we cannot solve problems we are not willing to confront.” But it gets problematic pretty quickly, with any “confronting” being done selectively. 

For instance, the report does not address the elephant in the room, that is, black Americans (13 percent of the population) account for roughly 50 percent of homicide offenders and victims. The most recent national data show the black victimization rate is eight times that of whites, with the great number of black crimes being intra-racial. 

Hmmm, that would be something you would think an organization dedicated to black advancement would want to address. Indeed, the report stays clear of anything touching on public safety or the justice system.

And a reader is left with the impression, although unstated, that discrimination by the white medical community might be somehow responsible for the higher rate of black infant mortality here. In fact, national studies show that black infants get more medical attention, and that relatively low birth weights rather than bigoted white physicians are the cause of the higher mortality.

Nor is there much time spent adding up the number of missing fathers. Only “single-parent” households (single mothers?) are tallied. That is telling, I thought.

Finally, there is the lamentation that blacks don’t do as well in our schools — a serious problem, granted, but one aggravated by three generations pursuing the impossible goals of social justice rather than practical classroom discipline and learning. Unmentioned is a national study finding that blacks with comparable IQ scores achieve the same income levels as other groups. Think about that one for a moment.

Perhaps that last was on the League president’s mind when she concluded, “It’s about accepting responsibility. After nearly a decade without this report, we have an opportunity to establish a renewed understanding of where we are today.”

Encouraging, or so one must hope. — tcl

Current Issue


Announcements


Free Newsletter

Stay months or even years ahead of the political discussion.