Franke: Post-Election Analysis

by Mark Franke

“Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want, and deserve to get it good and hard.” — H. L. Mencken

Mencken’s quote was published 110 years ago but is just as applicable today as then, especially if you are a Republican. Two years ago the Democrats and the never-Trumpers probably felt the same way.

A small group of Republican officeholders and conservative thinkers met shortly after the election under the auspices of the Indiana Policy Review Foundation to do a post-mortem on the election. Given the results, most entered the seminar room expecting to examine a corpse. Four hours later, most left more encouraged.

Clearly the voters were fed up with the ways things were going. Was it with Donald Trump and his erratic policies and microscopic attention span? Was it the failure of the Republican Congress and the Trump White House to deliver on the promises made in 2024? Were people just tired of the political drama? Or was it the age-old campaign issue “It’s the economy, stupid”?

Regardless, it was the Republican candidates all the way down the ballot who paid for the missteps in Washington.

One participant said he has never heard the phrase “getting back to normal” used so often in conversations with voters . . . and used in a way not conducive to returning incumbents to office. They just want to get back to living their lives and all the nonsense about renaming lakes and starting trade wars with allies confirms that Trump is not serious about the issues that matter to them.

Then there is the Iran war, supposedly a two-week affair that is still dragging on, and its effect on gasoline prices. Add overall inflation, exasperated by constant tariff increases, and it doesn’t take a PhD in economics to understand voter frustration with an underperforming economy, at least that part of the economy they confront daily at the cash register.

A report in the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette provided insight into the real effect of all this voter angst. Straight party voting in Allen County increased with a significant shift away from the Republican ticket to the Democrat. The data cannot be misinterpreted. Voters were fed up.

As one of our group reminded us: Challengers don’t win; incumbents lose.

That is a sad commentary on American democracy. It is not healthy for our republic when voters are more motivated negatively rather than positively. But that is where we find ourselves in this brave new world. 

The group eventually worked through the gloom and doom and moved on to discussing options going forward. Recall that in 2024 the national media all but buried the Democrat Party. As unstable as our electoral politics have become, there is no reason to write an obituary for the Republican Party. One is reminded of Mark Twain’s response to a news report of his death as being exaggerated. 

So what are the opportunities for the Republican Party in 2028?

There is every reason to expect the Democrat Socialists of America and the Democrat caucus to overreach just like the Trump faction did after 2024. Plus, the political calculus just doesn’t compute for sweeping change. The Democrats face the same legislative gridlock that frustrated the Republicans the past two years. They need to keep their caucuses disciplined — good luck with that — and there is the Senate’s 60 vote rule at least for now. Throw in presidential vetoes and it is hard to foresee a massive overhaul of our constitutional system.

It is now the turn of the Democrats to solve the budget deficit, the national debt and the impending insolvency of the Social Security trust fund. They won’t find their theoretical solutions any more palatable with Congress than the Republican Freedom Caucus found theirs.

Republicans must also show their seriousness with recreating their party in a credible manner. This requires what one of our group called a “clean sweep” of Congressional leadership to demonstrate that they listened to the voters. Time will tell if they succeeded with their leadership changes.

We all agreed that the key to Republican resurgence is to clearly outline a policy agenda reflecting conservative principles. (No wonder; all the participants were conservatives of one stripe or another.) This includes fiscal responsibility, limited governmental restrictions on personal liberty and an economy stimulated by entrepreneurial investment.

The wild card in all this is . . . Donald Trump. He views his office as dealmaker-in-chief so who knows what he will work out with the Democrat leadership. He has never been a philosophical conservative so he is not bound by any orthodoxy. He may even find more legislative friends on the Democrat side of the aisle than on the Republican if they can overcome their phobic Trump obsession. 

This is a clarion call to the GOP: Get organized. Get focused. Get busy. 

Mark Franke, M.B.A., an adjunct scholar of the Indiana Policy Review and its book reviewer, is formerly an associate vice-chancellor at Indiana University-Purdue University Fort Wayne. A version of this essay first appeared in this space on April 2, 2019.

Current Issue


Announcements


Free Newsletter

Stay months or even years ahead of the political discussion.