Essays
-
The Outstater
Read more: The OutstaterRodric’s Redistricting Guess INDIANA SENATE PRO-TEM Rodric Bray and ex-governors Mike Pence and Mitch Daniels, in tacitly opposing a redistricting measure that would have improved the national party’s position going into the midterm elections, have made a two-part tactical calculation — a political guess, if you will. The first part is that the Indiana supermajority is a reflection of grassroots GOP popularity. The second part is that opinion surveys accurately show redistricting to be unpopular. Republican values…
-
The Outstater
Read more: The Outstater‘The Mamdani Effect’ (Part II) “We will prove that there is no problem too large for government to solve and no concern too small for it to care about.” — Zohrnan MamdaniI READ that many cities are ready to make bids for businesses fleeing Zohran Mamdani’s New York. I assume that Indiana metropolises will be among them. The question, though, is in what way does the leadership here disagree with Mamdani. It is not clear to…
-
Clark: Are you a ‘Christian Nationalist’?
Read more: Clark: Are you a ‘Christian Nationalist’?Editor’s Note: The Indianapolis Star yesterday launched a series of articles beginning with “God and Politics: A once-fringe Christian movement gains influence in Indiana government.” It attempts, incredulously, to marginalize Christian teaching, the basis of both western civilization and the American experiment, as only a recent political tactic of extremists. Along the way, it butchers the concept of separation of church and state. We asked Micah Clark, a veteran of such battles, to share his initial views.…
-
The Outstater
Read more: The OutstaterAS A NEWSMAN I don’t have high expectations for modern journalism but we are at a new low. The media’s coverage of the congressional decision to shut down government demonstrates how close we are to tyranny. The press focused on the narrow issue of SNAP benefits rather than on the broader and more intractable issue of the congressional dysfunction leading up the shutdown. Why? Easier. It allowed a single person, the president, to be painted as the villain. If…
-
Franke: Supreme Court Independence
Read more: Franke: Supreme Court Independenceby Mark Franke Every year the Gallup organization conducts an opinion poll to determine the level of confidence Americans have for major institutions. It should come as no surprise that news organizations rank at the bottom with Congress and educational institutions also scoring high negatives. The confidence level in the Supreme Court of the U.S. is much more nuanced and not easy to decipher. Ever since the contentious Robert Bork nomination, names advanced by the…
-
The Outstater
Read more: The OutstaterThe NIMBY of Data Centers AS USUAL, the emotional argument is winning the day, this time against data centers. If you mingled with the crowd of anti-Google activists at a recent library town hall in Fort Wayne you would have met precious few engineers and zero economists. Rather, the one hundred or so in attendance can be characterized as informationally deprived NIMBY crackpots determined to “stick it to the man,” as we used to say. Our NAACP leadership…
-
The Outstater
Read more: The OutstaterThe Mamdani Effect “It is hard to imagine a more stupid or more dangerous way of making decisions than by putting those decisions in the hands of people who pay no price for being wrong.” — Thomas Sowell HAVING WORKED with words all my career, I have admired the economists’ turn of phrase. Shakespearean almost, they pack a lot into a few syllables. My favorite is “rational ignorance,” the realization that certain things are so confused that learning…
-
McGowan: AI Flunks the Baseball Test
Read more: McGowan: AI Flunks the Baseball Testby Richard McGowan, Ph.D. This year’s world series and all the attention paid to Shohei Ohtani reminded me of the way students used to get by when writing papers. They used CliffsNotes instead of doing research. Can AI be far behind? I had a bright student who wrote a paper on Plato’s “Crito” as explained by every student’s former cheat sheet, i.e., CliffsNotes. Conner discovered that CliffsNotes was woefully deficient. In its analysis of that Platonic dialogue, it never addressed history’s…
-
The Outstater
Read more: The OutstaterGrades: All Rhinestones Now “Personally, I liked working for the university. They gave us money and facilities. We didn’t have to produce anything. You’ve never been out of college. You don’t know what it’s like out there. I’ve worked in the private sector — they expect results.” — Dr. Raymond Stantz (Dan Aykroyd) in the 1984 movie “Ghostbusters.” A UNIVERSITY, as any institution, is justified by its product and function, that is, the service it provides society. You might…
-
Franke: Civic Bargain Book Review
Read more: Franke: Civic Bargain Book Reviewby Mark Franke One hears the word democracy so often these days — and in so many contexts — that it has lost its meaning. There is the tiresome charge that anything Donald Trump does is a threat to democracy on one hand and on the other hand a rather pedantic academic argument that we are not and never were a democracy, being a republic instead. One is tempted to just tune it all out if…