We can quit worrying about the sorry state of mass media. The fate of one sector (corporate newspapers) tells us what happens to readership/viewership when an adolescent mindset rules. The problem solves itself in a free market as better business models prevail.
The chart above shows how newspaper daily readership fell from roughly 70 percent saturation to below 20 percent (and falling). This trend was fully established, please know, well before the Internet kicked in. You can also note that as readership fell the rise in corporate ownership increased, either contributing to the fall or at best proving ineffectual in slowing it. Network news is just laughable.
As one of the ink-stained wretches who survived this period, I can give you a desk-eye view of what happened, of how newspapers died — and it didn’t have much to do with the Internet.
In a word, it was that the “agency” of those in management changed. Particularly, corporate owners replaced individual owners, a situation that now is the norm in mass media across all platforms.
I am using “agency” here to describe a person’s influence and role in an organization, the practical power to intervene in events to determine outcomes and product. A person has agency to the extent they can draw on resources, knowledge and a title to transform their institution, in this case a newsroom.
To pick up on our example, the agency of a newspaper publisher in the 1960s was one thing, the agency of a newspaper publisher in 2026 was something quite else. If we are going to restore independent, prescient mass media, It is important to know the difference.
For starters, the First Amendment, which allows the media extraordinary privileges, is awarded to individuals and not corporate boards. So this alone creates a disconnect. Add to that the wildly differing incentives of a hometown owner and of a carpetbagging manager and you have a formula for decline.
If you need an example of how that might play out, it is in yesterday’s Indianapolis Capital Chronicle, an editorial “sponsored” by an outside group, a decidedly liberal one.
So, yes, you can now buy this media outlet’s opinion, a transaction that would have been considered corrupt under individual ownership. The Indianapolis Star and other corporate newspaper have similar programs. They even go so far as to allow outside funding of the salaries of reporters covering politically sensitive beats such as the environment and affirmative action. No reader/viewer wants to pay for that. There is no readership trust there to justify advertising rates.
Finally, another factor in the information business has changed — news judgment. The adolescent mindset mentioned earlier included senior management. It is an attitude regardless of one’s age, often radically feminized, that things have to be made fair, must be equitable, that resentments are justified, that parents/governments need to make it right.
But without an individual owner, someone based in real-life experience with deep roots in the community and their own fortune at stake, newsrooms were left adrift. Specifically, they were without adult supervision in the setting of news criteria. Consider it a decades-long, miserably failed, experiment in journalism by Montessori,
It is a difficult thing to measure, but my sense is that each year we get more of our news from a dog’s breakfast of tweets, blogs and the offhand views of family, friends and neighbors. Sooner or later this will coalesce into something resembling traditional journalism — a journalism headed by mature, invested, individual owners sifting and sorting the news in the interest of their business and their community.
Looking at the chart, my guess is it will be sooner. — tcl

