Kind intentions, costly institutions — and what the record shows.
by Barry Keating, Ph.D.
In “Socialism an Adjunct to Democratic Society” (Journal Gazette, Nov. 6), Noor Borbieva O’Neill and Leonard Williams argue that socialism merely represents those advocating for “a just society in which no individual lacks the basic necessities of life and in which property and knowledge are shared fairly.” Defining socialism in terms of this ideal does not describe how socialism works in practice.
A more standard definition of socialism implies something specific: state ownership or direction of the means of production, with allocation by political decision, not by prices and voluntary exchange. Judging both the social and economic outcomes of nations that have practiced socialism is sobering.
Borbieva O’Neill and Williams, who identify as scholars on this topic, write that “…socialism implies a concern with the “sociability” instinct in human nature.” However, three economists cited below offer insight into why socialism actually reduces social interaction and fails to improve the lives of the majority of persons living under a socialist regime.
Consider the observations of Friedrich A. Hayek in The Road to Serfdom (1944), addressing “socialists of all parties.” He warned of two fundamental weaknesses of national socialism. First, Hayek argued, an economy runs on dispersed information in the minds of millions of persons — no planning board can collect and process this knowledge. Prices condense this information into signals anyone can use. Replace prices with a plan, and you get shortages and queues, and officials deciding who gets what is left.
Hayek goes on to identify the second problem of national socialism as power. A comprehensive plan requires agreement on policy goals — whose needs rank first, which institutions get funded, what agencies and towns must suspend infrastructure upgrades. Democracies do not agree on such things, so planning on a national level, Hayek argued, must be delegated to officials, who then impose particular commands on all participants. Official control, he wrote, is not limited to one sector of our lives; it begins to infect every aspect of personal and community life. To explain “Why the Worst Get on Top” in The Road to Serfdom, Hayek suggests that those planners most willing to coerce will be preferred and put in charge.
Robert Owen’s New Harmony, Indiana — cited fondly in the Journal Gazette article— was established in 1825 as a model community of cooperation and equality. There, production quickly began to lag consumption, and the arrangement had dissolved by 1827. Voluntary communes, like New Harmony, often cease to exist, but generally their members can simply leave. Unfortunately, state socialism persists for decades, and individuals find it difficult or impossible to exit.
Families can function more or less as idealistic model communities, but socialism does not scale up on a national level. Unfortunately, the extent of socialism’s failure can be measured in deaths. In Soviet Ukraine, forced collectivization and grain requisition, according to the 1932-33 Holodomor index, directly resulted in roughly 3.9 million excess deaths. In China, the Great Leap Forward of 1958–62 forced peasants into communes under impossible quotas; recent estimates of famine deaths range around 30 million and above. These were not natural disasters. This is what happens when socialists set quotas and control food production, the press, and borders.
Countries sharing the same culture but divided by socialist regimes tell a similar story. In 1950, East German income per person was roughly two-thirds of West Germany’s; by 1989 it had fallen to less than half — about $8,400 against about $18,000 in 1990 international dollars. East Germany built a wall to keep its citizens in, and at least 140 people were killed at the Berlin Wall attempting to escape West Germany between 1961 and 1989. Korea tells the same story: in 1970 North Korea was slightly richer per person than the South, about $325 to $260; by 2023, on United Nations figures, the North stood at $640, the South at $35,538.
It is not clear what the Journal Gazette article implies in presenting socialism as “an adjunct to democratic society.” Milton Friedman, perhaps the best-known free-market economist of the 20th century, had argued for an income safety net for those in distress. However, in Capitalism and Freedom (1962), Friedman stated the issue with socialism in no uncertain terms: economic freedom is “an indispensable means toward the achievement of political freedom,” and competitive capitalism promotes it “because it separates economic power from political power and in this way enables the one to offset the other.” If you displease your boss, you can seek another job. However, if the state is your only employer, as well as your landlord, grocer, doctor, and publisher, you are left with no options. Friedman taught us to judge policies by results, not intentions — a test socialism cannot pass.
Finally, we consider James Buchanan and Gordon Tullock’s approach to the politics of socialism. In The Calculus of Consent (1962) — for which Buchanan received the Nobel Prize in 1986 — Buchanan and Tullock refused to assume that once elected, officials become selfless and always act in the public interest. Tullock’s 1967 analysis of what Anne Krueger named “rent-seeking” showed the waste that follows when the state is in a position to grant favors to groups lobbying for them instead of producing anything of value. Like Borbieva O’Neill and Williams, these economists lament officials “beholden to moneyed interests.” However, Buchanan and Tullock’s public choice economics reverse the prescription: the more that life runs through politics, the greater special interests will have access. Socialism grants officials control and command over the larger economy and society.
The article’s figure on income and wealth inequality in the U.S. is broadly correct, but its conclusion does not follow. Income inequality does not fully describe U.S. living standards: it omits future Social Security and pension claims that many ordinary households chiefly rely on, and says nothing about whether the typical family is better fed, housed, and treated compared with its grandparents or those presently living in other countries. Venezuela, which expropriated private property, fixed prices and printed money in socialism’s name, achieved a grim equality: output shrank by about 75 percent between 2013 and 2021, and its population declined since 2015 by 7.9 million people — a quarter of all its residents.
The article closes claiming socialism safeguards “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” History suggests those rights are safeguarded by the opposite arrangements: private property giving a dissenter a livelihood, competing employers, a free press, courts binding planners as well as citizens, and a right to exit. Compassion is a virtue, practiced voluntarily. As a system for organizing production, socialism has repeatedly taxed it with shortages, capture and, at its worst, famine and walls. Fort Wayne readers should honor the authors’ ends — and decline their means.
The argument in one line:
Judge socialism not by the compassion it professes, but by the power it concentrates —
and by what that power has done wherever it has been tried.
Barry Keating, Ph.D., an adjunct scholar of the Indiana Policy Review Foundation, is Professor Emeritus of the Mendoza College of Business at the University of Notre Dame. A version of this essay will appear in the winter Indiana Policy Review.
